Preservation Magazine, Spring 2025

Designer Jennifer Ott Rehabilitates an Eichler House in Northern California

From our interview with designer and homeowner Jennifer Ott.

We were living in San Francisco. My husband, Russ Poldrack, is a professor at Stanford University, and he was commuting. I’m a designer and color consultant. I wanted to live in the city, but I told him that if he ever got sick of the commute, I would consider moving. Then COVID happened, and when he had to start taking the train back down to work, he was like, “Uh, I really don’t want to have to do this again.”

So we started looking, and everything’s expensive throughout the Bay Area, but in Palo Alto, [California], near Stanford particularly, it’s very expensive. I hadn’t fully understood this previously, but Stanford started allowing faculty to build homes on university-owned land in the late 1800s. There are around 900 of these homes on campus. The deal is that you can only buy them if you’re a qualifying Stanford faculty member. In our case, the price ended up being a little lower than if anyone in the area could buy it.

Portrait of Jennifer Ott and Russ Poldrack at home

photo by: Drew Kelly

Homeowners Jennifer Ott and Russ Poldrack.

Glass-covered atrium in Eichler house

photo by: Ken Gutmaker

An atrium is a classic Eichler house feature.

I started looking at these properties and saw that there were a number of Eichler houses. The whole manifesto of Joseph Eichler, the developer, was that he wanted to make good architecture accessible to the middle class. I’ve always been a fan of Eichler and Midcentury Modern architecture. So I told my husband, “If we can get into an Eichler, I’ll move.” And we ended up finding this one.

The house was designed by Claude Oakland and built in 1970. It’s just about 2,300 square feet. It had the same owner [the whole time]—he was a physician at Stanford and had the house built for his family. [From what I can tell,] they never did any remodeling. As much as we could, we tried to keep the original [materials and finishes].

The tongue-and-groove redwood ceiling is a hallmark of Eichler homes. The wood was stained a grayish-tan color to soften the redness. This was a semitransparent stain so that the grain was still visible. Our Eichler originally had that finish, but there were some areas with water stains. The seller was advised to paint over the ceilings versus trying to sand and re-stain them. I realize it would have been tough to match, and white ceilings are nice because they make the space so light and bright, but I wish I had had the chance to try to do some spot refurbishment of the stains. The original ceilings gave such a warm vibe, and the woodgrain was more interesting versus flat white.

Midcentury Fireplace in Eichler House

photo by: Ken Gutmaker

The living room's brick chimney remains unpainted.

Exterior of Eichler Home

photo by: Ken Gutmaker

Architect Claude Oakland designed the house.

We kept the footprint of the house intact except for the kitchen. It is a very large room, but it originally had a tiny island and not much countertop or deep storage space. It was designed in a different time, when people had less stuff. We kept the sink, the refrigerator, and the perimeter counters and cabinets in the same place. But we wanted a larger island, and the only way to expand it was to reorient it, turning it 90 degrees. We kept the original range hood shell intact and rotated it. This new configuration gives us much more storage space, as well as surface prep space.

Both of us love to cook. We’re avid chefs; we’re in there at the same time together. Hence we added a second sink, because the sink was always an area of congestion for us. So now we have two good-size sinks in there. It’s amazing how preparation and cleanup for dinner is so much easier and more fun. We can both be in there and we’re not in each other’s way. It’s that balance of making it functional while trying not to veer too far from the intended original aesthetic.

We did upgrade the cabinets and countertops in the kitchen and bathrooms. They were all laminate that was delaminating. There was no way to repair it, and we didn’t want to replace with more laminate that we knew wouldn’t be durable. We replaced them with maple-clad plywood cabinets and stone countertops. And we made some changes to the flooring, which was the original white shag wall-to-wall carpet, vinyl composition tile, and ceramic tile. All were in rough shape. But we again tried to keep it Midcentury Modern-esque. We’re pretty sure some of the vinyl tile contained asbestos. The trick with asbestos tile is either you have to do the remediation and removal, which is a huge process, or if it’s intact you can just cover over it. We covered it with a luxury vinyl tile that mimics gray limestone and has a lifetime warranty.

Stanford has a historic review process for on-campus, faculty-owned homes. When we bought the house, we had to consult with them about any exterior changes we were making. The biggest change to the front of the house we made was replacing the garage door, because it was a safety issue.

Midcentury Kitchen in Eichler House

photo by: Ken Gutmaker

Ott enhanced the kitchen's existing storage space.

We ran the plan by Stanford and replaced it with a very plain, [wood-panel] garage door, so it looks very similar to the original. We replaced all of the sliding doors and operable windows because they were in pretty bad shape. The new window frames are the exact same size and material, same thickness of frame around the doors and windows as before.

I’ve heard the style of our house called a double-gable atrium Eichler. I know the original Eichlers were more the flat-roofed ones. The element that most speaks to it being a later Eichler is that clipped gable on the front elevation. From the front, the house is pretty modest looking. But it’s kind of fun when people come over and they see the outside, and then they come through and see the atrium and the peaked internal gables. It’s just so much grander inside, and you have all the glass. There’s something nice about [that experience], when you see a house that’s modest from the front and then you go in and it opens up.

"I have to say there’s something nice about a house with a strong architectural point of view. You want to pay homage to what it previously was. It really limits what you can do and your material choices, and I find that liberating."

We have a very minimal, xeriscaped yard. It’s nothing fancy. But there’s something about sitting in the house. You feel like you’re outside, even though you’re not. I think that feeling of connection to the outdoors is amazing. And yet you have privacy. One really ingenious thing is the idea that the front of the house is kind of closed off. There’s this skinny slot window and the front door sidelights, and then my husband’s office has a slot window. Nobody can see in through the front, and we can’t see out, so we just really live in the atrium and the backyard. Even though it’s glass and it’s open, it feels very private, and it’s cozy. You don’t feel like you’re on display.

It’s a beautiful home but it’s also comfortable. It doesn’t feel like we’re living in a museum. It has that casual-California-living, inviting feel to it. I’m always noticing how planes come together in the house, because it is so open. Especially with all the rooms that connect to the atrium. You can tell there’s a lot of care and thought that went into the design of it. We’ve had subcontractors work on the house who remark on the same thing. The guy who installed the flooring said he could tell it was designed by a good architect.

I have to say there’s something nice about a house with a strong architectural point of view. You want to pay homage to what it previously was. It really limits what you can do and your material choices, and I find that liberating. Instead of having to choose between 50 different flooring options, you maybe have five. [Choosing] to be limited on the interior just made it so much easier and less stressful.

I served as the general contractor and then hired subcontractors. We used a licensed electrician for the electrical work and a licensed plumber for plumbing work. We had a skilled handyman who was amazing. He was almost more of a perfectionist than me.

[The people who worked on the house] appreciated the architecture. They saw that there was pride of design and workmanship and wanted to contribute to that in a way that kept it looking impressive.

Donate Today to Help Save the Places Where Our History Happened.

Donate to the National Trust for Historic Preservation today and you'll help preserve places that tell our stories, reflect our culture, and shape our shared American experience.

Headshot Meghan Drueding

Meghan Drueding is the executive editor of Preservation magazine. She has a weakness for Midcentury Modernism, walkable cities, and coffee-table books about architecture and design.

This May, for Preservation Month, we’re celebrating the power of place—and the countless ways, big and small, that preservation creates. Preservation Month is our chance to show why our work matters!

Celebrate!