Preservation Magazine, Summer 2016

News Brief: Raising the Bar at the Jail Hill Inn

Exterior shot of Jail Hill Inn

photo by: Courtesy Fallon Oldenburg/Jail Hill Inn

If they look closely, guests at the just-opened Jail Hill Inn in Galena, Illinois, will spot names such as Curly and Al carved into their window frames. The graffiti dates to the bed-and-breakfast’s century as Galena’s county jail, and it’s just one of the details owner Matthew Carroll left intact when he transformed the 8,000-square-foot, Second Empire–style building from a foreclosed government facility into luxury lodging.

Once home to Ulysses S. Grant, Galena draws more than a million tourists per year to its picture-perfect historic district. But native son Carroll says the property he acquired last year and rehabilitated with local contractors stands out for its fortress-like design.

The sturdy 1879 construction kept the jail in good shape during the decades it stood neglected after closing in 1977. Though a 1980s owner gutted the interior, visitors can still admire original beams and windows, as well as a brick ceiling built to provide an extra layer of security for the resident sheriff’s family. Modern amenities such as a wireless sound system complete the six-suite inn’s transformation.

“You only get a couple opportunities in your life to follow a dream and your passion,” says Carroll, a hospitality industry veteran who counts the Jail Hill Inn as his first preservation project. “It is a dream come true for me.”

The National Trust for Historic Preservation works to save America's historic places. Join us today to help protect the places that matter to you.

Join now!