Preservation Magazine, Spring 2025

Places Restored, Threatened, Saved, and Lost in Preservation Magazine's Spring 2025 Issue

In each Transitions section of Preservation magazine, we highlight places of local and national importance that have recently been restored, are currently threatened, have been saved from demolition or neglect, or have been lost. Here are five from Spring 2025.

A white three-story palatial structure with large Gothic-style arched windows. Behind it, the sky is blue and dotted with clouds.

photo by: East West Partners/Nick Cann Photo

Restored: Masonic Temple Building

After enlisting the prolific 19th-century architect John Henry Devereux to design their grand lodge building in Charleston, the Ancient Free Masons of South Carolina occupied the palatial 1872 building for the better part of the next 100 years. But during a mid-20th century renovation, the structure’s original Gothic-style arched windows were partially filled in. Now, a recent rehabilitation by developer East West Partners has brought the former Masonic temple back to its original look. By the time East West Partners became involved in 2019, the second and third floors had been vacant for roughly 50 years.

As part of a full restoration of the brick-and-stucco facade, the project team carefully replicated the original windows—a $2 million endeavor. It converted the upper floors into 12 residences while the ground floor remains occupied by retail space. “Our whole intent was to bring back that original architecture that was so well done back in the late 1800s,” says project manager Graham Worsham. Now known as 71 Wentworth after its current street address, the rehabilitated building was unveiled in November 2024.

The Palace Hotel sits on a street corner of downtown Ukiah, California. It's a brick, two-story building with scaffolding on the first floor.

photo by: Tom Carter

Saved: Palace Hotel

For decades, the Palace Hotel in Ukiah, California, sat vacant, deteriorating, and mired in uncertainty. There were various proposals over the years to save or demolish the building, but none came to fruition—until now. The Palace Hotel has hope in the form of a new steward. Local general contractor Tom Carter purchased the hotel in October 2024, with plans to restore it and eventually reopen it to guests. Carter secured a city permit in December to begin shoring up the building and sealing its roof to prevent further degradation. He’s looking for investors to join him in bringing the Palace back to prominence.

The hotel consists of four structures built between 1891 and 1929, with the earliest portion considered Ukiah’s finest example of brick construction from that period. In its heyday the Palace hosted a number of distinguished guests, including California governors and film stars, but it eventually shuttered in the 1980s and was left to deteriorate. Carter previously undertook a successful restoration of the Tallman Hotel in nearby Upper Lake, California, and he’s bringing his lifetime of construction experience to saving the Palace. “For me,” he says, “it’s the love of the building.”

Lost: Joliet Steel Works Main Office Building

After the Joliet Steel Works Main Office Building was named one of Landmarks Illinois’ Most Endangered Historic Places in 2021, things started to look up for the long-neglected structure in Joliet, Illinois. The Steel Works was one of the most productive steel plants in the United States at its peak around 1920. After it shuttered in the 1980s, the Main Office Building was locked and left vacant. Owner U.S. Steel agreed to stabilize the circa-1891 building with a new roof and gutters in 2021. The company also allowed the Joliet Area Historical Museum to remove and protect historic blueprints and documents found inside the building, which had served as the plant’s administrative offices.

City officials and local preservationists had long dreamed about potential ways to adaptively reuse the space. But hopes to eventually revive the limestone structure were dashed when it burned in a fire on Sept. 7, 2024. “The interior was very cool. It would’ve made a wonderful incubator space down the line, or even a museum or archive space,” says Quinn Adamowski, a Joliet resident and Landmarks Illinois regional advocacy manager. “We always felt, at least from the historian perspective, that it was a symbol of the strength and legacy of Joliet’s industrial heritage. … The loss of that building is pretty significant.”

The front facade of the Joliet Steel Works Main Office Building features an arched limestone entryway and weathered, blue-green front doors.

photo by: Landmarks Illinois

A historic train station covered in cedar shakes and red trim is seen in the foreground with a blue sky in the background.

photo by: Jim Lockard Photography

Restored: Aberdeen B&O Station

Following decades of neglect, a former rail station in Aberdeen, Maryland, escaped demolition in 2003. Now, after a recent restoration, the station looks just as it did when it was erected in 1885. Once a stop along a Baltimore and Ohio Railroad (B&O) train line, the building was designed by prolific Victorian-era architect Frank Furness in the Shingle Style, featuring a brick-and-cedar-shake exterior and a distinctive bulb-shaped chimney. (Furness designed more than 100 rail stations, but only a small fraction remain.) Passenger service at the Aberdeen B&O Station ceased in the 1950s, and it has sat empty since the early 1990s.

A feasibility study revealed that because freight trains have gotten bigger, the 2,585-square-foot structure was too close to the tracks, so the Maryland Historical Trust and The Historical Society of Harford County funded a relocation of the station about 50 feet from its original site in 2015. But it remained in poor condition until 2021, when its owner, the nonprofit Friends of the Aberdeen B&O Train Station, embarked on a $1.1 million restoration project designed by David H. Gleason Associates and executed by Bathon Builders. The team made structural repairs, swapped lead paint–ridden cedar shakes for replicas, and sourced color-matched bricks to replace those that were failing. “The windows and doors are either original or they’re reproduced to the original,” says historic consultant Mary Rasa. The exterior restoration was completed in July 2024. The Friends group is preparing to tackle an interior rehabilitation this year, with plans to eventually rent out the space and create an exterior public interpretation component.

A two-story historic log tavern is seen with a night sky in the background.

photo by: Tall James Photography

Threatened: Overfield Tavern

In the early morning hours of Dec. 7, 2024, a fire broke out at the Overfield Tavern Museum in Troy, Ohio. Flames ripped through the museum’s two log structures—a cabin and a tavern, both more than 200 years old—destroying historic furnishings, clothing, and art. Miraculously, the buildings’ hewn-log construction is still largely intact, a testament to “just how sturdy those old-growth logs are,” says Ben Sutherly, the museum’s board president. Early Ohio settlers Benjamin and Margaret Overfield built the one-room log cabin in 1803 as a place to raise their children. The 1,080-square-foot tavern, completed next door a few years later, was the cornerstone of Troy’s early community. After the tavern ceased operating in 1824, it saw a wide variety of uses: a residence, a clubhouse frequented by local industrialists, and even a preschool.

The Overfield Tavern Museum was founded in the mid-1990s and completed a major restoration. Over the following 30 years, it steadily added to its existing collection. A new exhibit on the tavern’s second floor was unveiled in March 2024, but it and many other displayed objects burned in the December blaze. The museum is raising money through The Troy Foundation to restore what’s left. Executive Director M. Chris Manning hopes to reopen in some capacity by the end of 2026. “We lost a lot,” she says. “It really was the birthplace of the Troy community.”

Donate Today to Help Save the Places Where Our History Happened.

Donate to the National Trust for Historic Preservation today and you'll help preserve places that tell our stories, reflect our culture, and shape our shared American experience.

Preservation magazine Assistant Editor Malea Martin.

Malea Martin is the assistant editor at Preservation magazine. Outside of work, you can find her scouring antique stores for mid-century furniture and vintage sewing patterns, or exploring new trail runs with her dog. Malea is based on the Central Coast of California.

This May, for Preservation Month, we’re celebrating the power of place—and the countless ways, big and small, that preservation creates. Preservation Month is our chance to show why our work matters!

Celebrate!