Detroit's El Moore Building Gets An Eco-Friendly Rehab
Just after Detroit developers and community leaders Tom and Peggy Brennan purchased the El Moore building in 2010, their associate Jason Peet happened to notice a nearby road crew throwing old curbstones into dump trucks. Peet didn’t know exactly what he’d do with the stones, but he knew he could do something. He approached the crew’s boss, and they struck a deal—$100 worth of pizza in exchange for delivering the curbstones down the street instead of dropping them at a landfill.
As it turned out, some of the curbstones were a distinctive brownish-pink hue, just like the Lake Superior sandstone that covers the El Moore’s 1898 exterior. They’d been laid before 1910, which meant they probably came from some of the same northern Michigan or Upper Peninsula quarries as the Romanesque Revival building’s stones. Peet and the Brennans ended up using them to build the columns that now grace the El Moore’s driveway and gate entrances.
“We never could’ve had these pillars that matched the building so well if we didn’t have those curbs,” says Peet, the building’s manager.
The episode encapsulates the Brennans’ serendipitous, community-oriented experience converting the turreted structure into its current incarnation, a combination of 12 private residences and 11 hotel rooms, including four added rooftop “cabins.” Tom Brennan is a retired management consultant, and in 2008 he and Peggy, both native Michiganders, started the Green Garage, a sustainable business incubator housed in a former Model T showroom in Detroit’s Midtown neighborhood.
“We’re trying to help jump-start Detroit’s economy,” Peggy explains.The Green Garage currently houses 55 small, local businesses. It has also established the couple’s reputation for a commitment to sustainability and a creative streak when it comes to repurposing old materials. The latter turned out to be a handy skill for rehabbing the El Moore, which is located on Alexandrine Street, less than a half mile from the Green Garage. The only way to salvage many of the building’s existing components—far removed from their original uses after decades of remodeling, decline, and neglect—was to think creatively.
The El Moore was probably given its grandiose name by its original owner, a banker and state senator named Charles W. Moore. The design is the work of A.C. Varney, a prominent Detroit architect at the time. Moore lived in a mansion on the corner, separated from the El Moore property by a two-family house. Both buildings have long since been demolished, and the Brennans are currently converting these two vacant lots into a community park called the El Moore Greens. (Radio deejay Casey Kasem grew up in a house on the other side of the El Moore; it, too, is gone.)
The El Moore contained eight luxury apartments—unusual for a neighborhood then dominated by large single-family houses. Also unusual was the building’s power setup: From the start, it was equipped with fully wired lighting and electrical outlets, features that had only been showing up in Detroit houses for a few years before the El Moore was built, says Peet. Because people were still suspicious about the new technology, many lights also had gas pipes built in, just in case residents needed to revert to gas lamps.
Varney designed two flats per floor, each with a pair of fireplaces and a maid’s bedroom. There were dumbwaiters and a skylit central shaft that allowed each bathroom, situated toward the middle of the building, to have a small, crank-operated window for ventilation. (The light shaft was still open when the Brennans and their team started work, and some of the pulley system and fragments of the rope remained.)
This luxe life didn’t last long, though. By the early 20th century, Detroit was a rapidly industrializing city, with a population growing just as fast. The El Moore’s history at this point is patchy, but Peet and the Brennans researched it as thoroughly as they could, cross-referencing the address with lists of city dwellers so they could guess how many residents the building had at different points.
“We believe it was divided into a boarding-house of at least 38 units,” Peet says. “We know that as the city expanded, the neighborhood went from being a high-end residential area on the outskirts to becoming the center of a city that was doubling in size every decade.” It’s unclear when Moore’s ownership of the building ended, and it appears that the El Moore became vacant sometime in the 1990s.
By the time the Brennans entered the picture, there were large holes in the roof. In the original main entrance, marble wall panels had fallen and shattered. Scavengers carted off the antique fireplaces, which fetch big money on the resale market. Before the economic crash of 2008, the building had been slated for a condominium and retail development, but that project never got off the ground. Finally, it went into foreclosure—and so did the bank that foreclosed on it. Ultimately the El Moore landed under the control of the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC).
Watching the building sit vacant, Susan Mosey, executive director of the planning and development organization Midtown Detroit, feared it would go to auction as a foreclosed FDIC asset. So she called the Brennans.
“This is just a spectacular skin on this building,” Mosey says. “I had worked with the Brennans on the Green Garage. I knew they’d been wonderful stewards of the property and that they’re very visionary.”
The Brennans and their team saw the building’s significance to the neighborhood, both as a piece of history and as a symbol of Detroit’s larger trauma of abandoned buildings, empty lots, and dilapidated architecture. Alexandrine Street, Peet says, was the last Midtown street heading south from busy Warren Avenue that still had at least 50 percent of its building stock. Were the El Moore to be demolished, the “first” house would be almost halfway down the block. Or, the building—with its roughly 16,000 square feet, crenellated design, and architectural history—could undergo yet another makeover and serve as a stabilizer.
“This building makes the whole block work,” Peet says.
The Brennans wanted to create a place that would contribute to the community. So they came up with the idea of a combination of apartments and hotel rooms, adding the rooftop cabins to make the whole project economically viable. “Existing buildings, I think they all have a nature. I almost feel like they’re living beings,” Tom Brennan says. “You just have to get to know them a bit and figure out what the possibilities are for the future.” The dual setup would create an interactive community experience, where visitors could meet residents and spend time in a Detroit neighborhood.
Luckily, the front of the building was in mostly good shape. (The front steps, too worn and thin to remain in service, were replaced with new, neutrally colored sandstone that would complement the rest of the stonework.) Because of the Green Garage, people knew about the Brennans and their commitment to the community, and the renovation became something of a crowdsourced project. A local stonemason, for instance, had salvaged chunks of sandstone from a demolished church nearby. He kept them in his backyard until the El Moore project came up, and they ended up forming the replacements for the building’s missing balcony corbels. Likewise, a friend of the Brennans owned some of the original iron railings, which had been auctioned off years before. The El Moore team hired Detroit blacksmithing outfit Smith Shop to replicate them, resulting in seamless balconies made of both old and new materials.
At a meeting of the Detroit Historic District Commission, the Brennans met a man who was replacing his old tiled roof. The tiles ended up on top of the new greenhouse they built to fill in the gap between the El Moore and the next building on the street. A large water tower that used to grace an old Cadillac dealership lives on, too: The body of the tank will be turned into an arched park entrance, and the legs became the supports for El Moore residents’ back decks and an exterior stairwell.
In planning new additions, local designer Woody Melcher respected the property’s historic spirit. A slim elevator tower and main entrance are set back to let the existing building stand out, and their minimalist modern design makes it clear that they are new. The greenhouse consists mostly of old, salvaged materials. And, because the El Moore is in a historic district, the added rooftop cabins are positioned so they can’t be seen from Alexandrine Street.
Inside, the team had a unique solution for the El Moore’s disrepair. For missing architectural features, they took what scraps they could salvage to create one historical composite. All the usable baseboards and window trim have been consolidated in the first-floor parlor. Out of 16 original fireplaces, the crew found only scattered parts, but used them to make the parlor’s fireplace.
In the Brennans’ view, the preservation and green building movements are natural allies. “We’re trying to create something that honors the past, takes the story and the narrative of the past, and then connects it to a sustainable future,” Tom Brennan says. “I don’t think you can get to a sustainable future unless you know your history.”
As part of its overall sustainable mission, the building produces much of its own energy from solar panels on the roof. The team’s goal is to use just 20 percent of the energy of a typical residential building, and they assess energy consumption each month to make sure they’re continuing to reduce the El Moore’s carbon footprint. A 4,250-gallon rainwater cistern and sub-parking-lot reserve collect water that’s used for landscaping. The El Moore also employs a geothermal heating system, which takes advantage of consistent ground temperatures to keep heating and cooling bills low.
The Brennans’ goals follow the so-called “triple bottom line” approach, which balances environmental, financial, and social good. Economically, the income from the hotel rooms supports the building’s eco-friendly design features and helps keep its residential component affordable. The hotel component also adds to the sense of community, which the Brennans have worked hard to foster in ways large and small. The first-floor parlor, for example, has no shades or obstructive landscaping in front of it, so that passersby can peek in. “If someone walks by, they’ll see people sitting at the table in the window, and they almost always wave,” Peet says. “These little connections are a big deal.”
“I don’t think you can get to a sustainable future unless you know your history.”Tom Brennan
Residents moved into the building the summer before the hotel’s February 2016 opening, so they could have the space to themselves for a while and get to know one another. (The Brennans, seeking a lively mix, filled the El Moore with four generations of residents; the youngest is 2 years old, and the oldest are in their 60s.) The apartments, which range from 360 to 720 square feet, occupy the second through fourth floors, while the hotel rooms are on the garden level, the first floor, and the new fifth floor. The arrangement encourages mingling among guests and residents. (One couple who stayed here several times and befriended some of the residents eventually moved in.)
Apartment dwellers also work in the hotel, which has been a perk for resident Harriet Green, a retiree who staffs the welcome desk. In her time at the El Moore, she’s met people from 27 countries and 38 states. “The people who live here have created a community that is great to come home to,” she says.
The El Moore helps that sense of community extend into the city, as well. There is no hotel bar, restaurant, or room service, although there is a continental breakfast for both guests and residents in the front parlor each morning. The idea is to encourage visitors to explore the neighborhood and the city more broadly by patronizing outside establishments.
All these small gestures add up to more interactions among people—an act of community preservation, in a way. “You reestablish all the things that people loved about neighborhoods 100 years ago, and what’s beautiful is, you just see it naturally playing itself out,” says Peet. “There’s a reason that neighborhoods 100 years ago were built the way they were.”