May 2, 2017

How To Think Like Jane Jacobs

Jane Jacobs

photo by: Wikimedia Commons

As we hit Jane Jacob’s 101st birthday this year (which coincides with Preservation Month), it’s fitting that we take a moment to think not only about why her theories have influenced city planning and preservation for decades, but how she came to form them in the first place.

Jacobs had no formal training in urban planning, nor was she an architect, or even a self-proclaimed preservationist. But today preservationists and urbanists alike recognize the significance of her ideology—what works and what doesn’t—and how it continues to shape our cities.

Preservation Month is the perfect time to think about the places that matter to us, and why. So we’ve come up with a few words of wisdom from Jacobs to help you think more like her, long after May is over.

1. “While you are looking, you might as well also listen, linger, and think about what you see.”

Jacobs moved from Scranton, Pennsylvania, to New York City to become a journalist. When she was working for Architectural Forum, she was assigned to the city-planning beat, about which she knew nothing.

So, she educated herself. She would walk or ride her bike all around Manhattan, asking questions about the city’s planners: What were their goals? Were they successful? If they failed, why? Jacobs searched for answers on what made a city a place that people could live in and be happy.

2. “Cities have the capability of providing something for everybody, only because, and only when, they are created by everybody.”

Jacobs believed that the problem with city planners of the preceding century—and with her contemporaries—was that they planned for the short term and without much input from the people who would be affected. She advocated for a bottom-up approach to ensure that people living in cities would be able to shape (and love) where they live.

3. “When we deal with cities we are dealing with life at its most complex and intense. Because this is so, there is a basic esthetic limitation on what can be done with cities: a city cannot be a work of art.”

Jacobs knew city life was “chaos,” but the good kind. Cities and city neighborhoods thrive when they can develop naturally, with the people who live there making that change happen. Appreciating the natural order of neighborhood life was, to Jacobs, the key to creating robust cities.

Louisville Main Street

photo by: Louisville images

Louisville, Kentucky's Main Street.

4. “The point of cities is multiplicity of choice.”

Jacobs believed a city thrived when people had options, specifically in transportation. If a person has the choice to either walk or take the bus, they will choose the option that best fits their needs, and that may change week to week.

Overall, she preferred pedestrian traffic over automobile traffic. Jacobs saw in her own neighborhood, Greenwich Village, that wide sidewalks and pedestrian-friendly blocks that encouraged walking would create a more vibrant and thriving city because people and neighborhoods would not be so isolated.

5. “Intricate minglings of different uses in cites are not a form of chaos. On the contrary, they represent a complex and highly developed form of order.”

According to Jacobs, the city is an ecosystem. The most basic ecosystem relies on varied interactions of living and non-living organisms that alone could not survive. It is only when all parts of an ecosystem connect and overlap that each part contributes to a whole.

When the interacting components of cities are divided, a city cannot thrive. A city with a designated shopping district, for example, creates a lonely and potentially unsafe part of the city after dinner time, when the shops close and few people remain. A strictly residential neighborhood has a familiar pattern in which people’s habits (sleeping, going to work, coming home, etc.) create a monotonous and predictable cycle that rarely varies. This doesn’t create a thriving city. It encourages separation and dulls city life.

Cities need blocks of mixed-use communities and neighborhoods that naturally create a sustainable city ecosystem.

The view of New York City from above with a mix of old and new buildings.

photo by: Aurelien Guichard/Flickr/CC BY SA 2.0

In New York City, you will find a mix of the old with the new.

6. “Old ideas can sometimes use new buildings. New ideas must use old buildings.”

Old buildings are crucial to thriving cities. Jacobs was a fan of using existing over new buildings whenever possible. She knew cities needed diversity not only in its people and businesses, but also in its buildings.

Today, we at the National Trust refer to her vision as ReUrbanism. It builds upon Jacobs’ ideas for today, championing for adaptive reuse of older buildings. As she saw, maintaining and reusing existing building stock in cities often leads to positive change, including more people, more entrepreneurial activity, and thus more diversity.

7. “Streets and their sidewalks—the main public places of a city—are its most vital organs.

Jacobs used a bottom-up approach to view the city and determine how to make cities work. At the core of her message were the street and its sidewalks. She liked short blocks with a multitude of different businesses, attractions, and housing that fostered community and visual diversity.

8. "Life attracts life"

This may seem the simplest of Jacobs’ assertions, but it remains a powerful truth of cities. A thriving city is unique because it has so many people living and working close together. We move to cities because we want to be around people and the everyday bustle. A lively neighborhood attracts lively people. If people are not attracted, the area becomes stagnant. This is the foundation through which cities are built.

Though cities have changed in ways that both celebrate Jacobs’ vision and show room for improvement since she first published her book, The Death and Life of Great American Cities, in 1961, many of her ideas remain relevant 60 years later.

So the next time you walk through a city like Seattle, Chicago, or Boston, and especially through your own community, look around and ask yourself: How do we keep our cities vibrant and thriving? Why do these places matter?

Meghan White is a historic preservationist and an editorial assistant for Preservation magazine. She has a penchant for historic stables, absorbing stories of the past, and one day rehabilitating a Charleston single house.

mwhite@savingplaces.org

Este Lugar Me Importa: Your donation will send much needed supplies to help the recovery efforts in Puerto Rico.

Help Now