May 23, 2018

Dead Brutalist Buildings

  • By: Teresa Mathew, CityLab

This story originally appeared on CityLab. Find the original here.

Robin Hood Gardens, London.

photo by: Oliver Wainwright

Robin Hood Gardens, London.

Sunlight dances across the exterior of a theater that looks half-eaten, its gaping holes and exposed wires open to the sky. Half-destroyed apartment buildings sit placidly, their glass windows not yet shattered. A church slowly gets chewed away by machinery.

These images and others are part of “Brutalist Destruction,” an exhibit that aimed to make viewers think about the impact of destroying Postwar concrete buildings. The exhibit, curated by Chris Grimley, opened in April at the pinkcomma gallery in Boston and ran through May 3, 2018.

A new show uses photographs of concrete buildings in their final days to argue for their preservation.

Over the last few years, Grimley noticed that an increasing number of Brutalist buildings around the country were being demolished and photographers were there to document them. “Eventually—unfortunately—there were enough of them to cull together into the show,” he said. Some of the photographers featured in “Brutalist Destruction” had worked with Grimley before, while others he reached out to after finding their work online.

Shoreline Apartments, Buffalo, New York.

photo by: David Torke

Shoreline Apartments, Buffalo, New York.

The show includes photos of Mechanic Theatre in Baltimore; Orange County Government Center in Goshen; Shoreline Apartments in Buffalo; Third Church of Christ in Washington, D.C.; and Prentice Women's Hospital in Chicago. Two U.K. buildings—London’s Robin Hood Gardens and Birmingham’s Public Library—are also in the show.

Boston Public Library's Renovation Proves Brutalism Has a Place Today

The removal of the granite plinths makes a stunning difference.

Philip Johnson’s buildings elicited responses as strong and disparate as his designs. He critiqued himself, admitting, for example, that his 1972 Brutalist addition to the Boston Public Library's main branch in Copley Square didn’t come out quite the way he intended. More than 40 years later, William Rawn Associates (WRA) led a multi-faceted renovation of the addition that used “Johnsonian principals” to respect the architect’s design while pushing the structure’s form and function into the 21st century.

Such structures are seen by some as “monstrosities” but, Grimley noted, regardless of style, they are simply products of and testaments to their time. He pointed out that 50 years after the rise of Victorian architecture there was a wave of “venomous dislike” for such buildings, which led to many of them being destroyed. “Now, we’d be like, ‘that’s so short-sighted and narrow-minded,’” said Grimley. And yet, he added, critics of Brutalism and those who call for their demolition are following the same course.

Preservation is a matter of ecology as much as aesthetics. “There’s this phrase that’s bandied about a lot: the greenest structure is the one that’s already there,” Grimley said. “The amount of energy, whether it’s labor of the people that made it, the actual material energy of the building itself, or the embodied energy it takes to remove it—it’s wasteful on so many fronts.”

Orange County Government Center, Goshen, New York.

photo by: Harlan Erskine

Orange County Government Center, Goshen, New York.

Mechanic Theater, Baltimore, Maryland.

photo by: Matthew Carbone

Mechanic Theater, Baltimore, Maryland.

Grimley has a favorite monstrosity of his own: Boston City Hall. “It’s a perennial punching bag for critics, but for us it’s one of the most fascinating and complicated buildings for the 20th century,” said Grimley. He encourages those who dislike the building to re-think the façade and what it represents. “It’s a singular piece of work made at a time when there was a newfound civic investment in infrastructure in Boston,” he said. “It signaled that Boston wasn’t the crusty 1950s version of Beantown, but something that was aggressively trying to become involved in the future.”

Girmley said he hopes that visitors to the exhibit will confront their own biases about the polarizing architectural style as more and more of these buildings face the wrecking ball.“Realize that just because something isn’t to your taste,” he added, “that doesn’t mean it shouldn’t have the chance to age gracefully.”

By: Teresa Mathew, CityLab

Have a story idea that might be interesting and engaging for a national audience? Read our Contributor Guidelines and email us at editorial@savingplaces.org.

More posts by guest authors (325)

Announcing the 2024 list of America’s 11 Most Endangered Historic Places.

See the List